• Submit Poetry
  • Support SCP
  • About Us
  • Members
  • Join
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Society of Classical Poets
  • Poems
    • Beauty
    • Culture
    • Satire
    • Humor
    • Children’s
    • Art
    • Ekphrastic
    • Epic
    • Epigrams and Proverbs
    • Human Rights in China
    • Music
    • Performing Arts
    • Riddles
    • Science
    • Song Lyrics
    • The Environment
    • The Raven
    • Found Poems
    • High School Poets
    • Terrorism
    • Covid-19
  • Poetry Forms
    • Sonnet
    • Haiku
    • Limerick
    • Villanelle
    • Rondeau
    • Pantoum
    • Sestina
    • Triolet
    • Acrostic
    • Alexandroid
    • Alliterative
    • Blank Verse
    • Chant Royal
    • Clerihew
    • Rhupunt
    • Rondeau Redoublé
    • Rondel
    • Rubaiyat
    • Sapphic Verse
    • Shape Poems
    • Terza Rima
  • Great Poets
    • Geoffrey Chaucer
    • Emily Dickinson
    • Homer
    • Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
    • Dante Alighieri
    • John Keats
    • John Milton
    • Edgar Allan Poe
    • William Shakespeare
    • William Wordsworth
    • William Blake
    • Robert Frost
  • Love Poems
  • Contests
  • SCP Academy
    • Educational
    • Teaching Classical Poetry—A Guide for Educators
    • Poetry Forms
    • The SCP Journal
    • Books
No Result
View All Result
Society of Classical Poets
  • Poems
    • Beauty
    • Culture
    • Satire
    • Humor
    • Children’s
    • Art
    • Ekphrastic
    • Epic
    • Epigrams and Proverbs
    • Human Rights in China
    • Music
    • Performing Arts
    • Riddles
    • Science
    • Song Lyrics
    • The Environment
    • The Raven
    • Found Poems
    • High School Poets
    • Terrorism
    • Covid-19
  • Poetry Forms
    • Sonnet
    • Haiku
    • Limerick
    • Villanelle
    • Rondeau
    • Pantoum
    • Sestina
    • Triolet
    • Acrostic
    • Alexandroid
    • Alliterative
    • Blank Verse
    • Chant Royal
    • Clerihew
    • Rhupunt
    • Rondeau Redoublé
    • Rondel
    • Rubaiyat
    • Sapphic Verse
    • Shape Poems
    • Terza Rima
  • Great Poets
    • Geoffrey Chaucer
    • Emily Dickinson
    • Homer
    • Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
    • Dante Alighieri
    • John Keats
    • John Milton
    • Edgar Allan Poe
    • William Shakespeare
    • William Wordsworth
    • William Blake
    • Robert Frost
  • Love Poems
  • Contests
  • SCP Academy
    • Educational
    • Teaching Classical Poetry—A Guide for Educators
    • Poetry Forms
    • The SCP Journal
    • Books
No Result
View All Result
Society of Classical Poets
No Result
View All Result
Home Essays

Commentary: Three Tributes to Formalist Poetry by Alan Nordstrom

March 1, 2013
in Essays, Poetry
A A
0
poems Commentary: Three Tributes to Formalist Poetry by Alan Nordstrom

Verse Forms as Evokers of Poetry

I wish to dispute the notion that a “poem” arrives in the formal poet’s mind as if it were a compressed computer file, which he or she then expands into the poem proper by versifying it.  Somewhat similar to this conception of versecrafting is the procedure Ben Jonson said he employed, of composing his poems first in prose and then translating them into verse.  If that was indeed his method, then he ought rightly to be called a “versifier,” one who makes over one kind of writing into another, just as does a translator of verse from one language into another, such as Chapman, Pope, and Fitzgerald have done in translating Homer.

My experience, at least, is otherwise: the less I know in advance of what I’m going to write in one form or another, the happier the results.  Committing myself to playing the game of a particular form—a sonnet, a villanelle, heroic couplets, a sestina, a limerick, a haiku—is like sitting down to a chessboard and beginning that game.  I may have a strategy in mind, a general drift I hope to follow, but it all depends on the opposition I encounter whether the game will proceed as I wish it to initially.  Plenty of surprises pop up along the way, and unforeseen adjustments and accommodations must be made—just as in whitewater rafting when you have to respond spontaneously to the sudden rocks and dips and bends rushing at you.  So it is with the unforeseeable exigencies of meter and rhyme constantly confronting the versemaker as the stream of thought tumbles along.

I see verse forms chiefly as evokers of new thought, rather than as conveyors of ready-made thought.  Rather than beginning with a “poem in the mind”—a sort of Platonic idea of a poem that is yet to be embodied and realized in the particular verbal vestments of a verse—I begin with an initial notion, a phrase, a line at most, and start to write.  Quite likely from habit it emerges in iambic pentameter or tetrameter, and I go on from there to discover whether I’ll rhyme the next line or the one after or maybe none at all.  But if, as is usual, I commit to a rhyme scheme, then I give myself even less likelihood of knowing in advance where my verses will take me, and the adventure of discovery begins in earnest.  Then the metrical and rhyming imperatives will evoke from my subconscious mind whatever sense I need to make in order to spin out the thread of thought that ties my poem together: and voilà!

“How do I know what I think till I see what I say?”—that old adage for essayists goes doubly for versecrafters, or at least for me.  The composing process is full of surprises, unexpected turns of thought, sudden revelations.  “No surprise for the poet,” said Frost, “no surprise for the reader.”  I know what he meant.

Why I Write Formalist Verse

I write verses in traditional forms like sonnets and iambic pentameter couplets because I enjoy reading great poems in that traditional style and seek to imitate, emulate and update its artistry, turning it to contemporary matters and idioms, while preserving its ancient musicality and lyric allure.

Let other poets experiment and innovate, as they have done over the last century, establishing new aesthetic parameters, new modes and manners of poetry—a word that at root indicates nothing more than “something made,” the poet being but “a maker.”  Yet what I prefer to make are words that sing, sweet words in measured verses, rhythmically aligned, that carry out a thought, yet bring more sense to sense through aural harmony.

(For those with ears to hear, the previous sentence contains a quatrain.)

Why I Write Sonnets

Why is a sonnet my favorite verse form to write?

Because it offers me the most adventurous hour or two I can spend while sitting in an easy chair—mentally adventurous.

The process of writing a sonnet continuously drives my mind in novel, unpremeditated directions, seeking out rhymes that advance and invent my thoughts on the fly, thoughts shaped as well by the metrical hurdles each iambic foot must leap or skip.

In fourteen pentameter lines, approximately 140 syllables, a small journey of discovery unfolds, looping from quatrain to quatrain, perhaps taking a turn of thought at the sestet, while seeking a destination that won’t be known until the last rhyme rings home to shut the couplet and seal the poem.

ShareTweetPin
The Society of Classical Poets does not endorse any views expressed in individual poems or commentary.
Read Our Comments Policy Here

RandomPoems

A Poem on the George Stephanopoulos and Nancy Mace Interview, by Warren Bonham
Poetry

A Poem on the George Stephanopoulos and Nancy Mace Interview, by Warren Bonham

March 21, 2024

. Victim Shaming Nancy Mace, a U.S. Congresswoman for South Carolina, was interviewed by George Stephanopoulos, former Communications Director for...

A Heroic Crown of Sonnets in Honor of the Ever Virgin, by Karen Darantière
Beauty

A Heroic Crown of Sonnets in Honor of the Ever Virgin, by Karen Darantière

July 27, 2024

. A Heroic Crown of Sonnets in Honor of the Ever Virgin . ---1st Mystery: The Prophecy of Isaiah ....

Next Post
Art Analysis: Gustave Jean Jacquet by Kara Lysandra Ross

Art Analysis: Gustave Jean Jacquet by Kara Lysandra Ross

2013 Poetry Journal Released

2013 Poetry Journal Released

'Zombie Dawning' and Other Poetry by James Ph. Kotsybar

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. Joseph S. Salemi on ‘The Wall of Separation’ and Other Poetry by Roy E. PetersonNovember 18, 2026

    The metaphor of "the ship of state" is an extremely old one, and can be traced all the way back…

  2. Roy Eugene Peterson on ‘The Wall of Separation’ and Other Poetry by Roy E. PetersonNovember 18, 2026

    David, I am humbled by your praise and thank you for your sharing the words of John Adams with us.

  3. Roy Eugene Peterson on ‘The Wall of Separation’ and Other Poetry by Roy E. PetersonNovember 18, 2026

    Thank you, Brian for your comments and setting up further discussion (perhaps a paean to the law of unintended consequences).…

  4. Roy Eugene Peterson on ‘The Wall of Separation’ and Other Poetry by Roy E. PetersonNovember 18, 2026

    Bless you, Briana. There is much to say about "The Wall of Separation." I may add some material later on…

  5. Roy Eugene Peterson on ‘The Wall of Separation’ and Other Poetry by Roy E. PetersonNovember 18, 2026

    Thank you, Russel, for your kind appraisal.

Subscribe to Daily Poems

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,660 other subscribers
No Result
View All Result

Recent Poems

  • ‘The Wall of Separation’ and Other Poetry by Roy E. Peterson
  • SCP Poetry Symposium and Public Reading—June 2027
  • ‘A Villanelle from a Hill in Hell’ by C.B. Anderson
  • ‘Truce’: A Sonnet by Vernon Speed
  • ‘As You Leave’: A Poem by Michael Charles Maibach
  • ‘Poetry, Again?’: A Poem by Rachel Christensen 
  • ‘My Salute to Golden Era Thespians’: A Poem by Mark Stellinga
  • ‘After Dante’: Sonnets by James Edward Green
  • ‘Autumn Haunts’: A Poem by Cynthia Erlandson
  • ‘Praying for Patience’: A Poem by Briana Reavis
  • ‘Fractal’: A Poem on Suicidal Depression, by Golan Shahar
  • ‘Laughing’: A Poem by Jeffrey Essmann
  • ‘Childproof Caps’ and Other Poems by Russel Winick
  • ‘Daylight Savings Crime’ and Other Poetry by Jan Mennite
  • ‘Ambient Political Precarity’ and Other Poetry by Alec Ream
  • ‘To Actias Luna (The Luna Moth)’: A Poem by Jeff Kemper
  • ‘Portals’ and Other Poetry by Janice Thompson
  • ‘Purple Reign’: A Poem by Susan Jarvis Bryant
  • ‘Grand-Guignol de Paris’: A Poem by Brian Yapko
  • ‘Intrepid Travelers’: A Poem by Paulette Calasibetta
  • ‘The Future of Society’: A Poem by Roy E. Peterson
  • ‘On Earth As It Is in Heaven’ and Other Poems by C.B. Anderson
  • ‘Michelangelo’: A Poem by Margaret Brinton
  • ‘Election Issue’: A Poem by Stephen DiLauro
  • ‘Saturday’s Child’: A Poem by Mary Cecelia Bowman
  • ‘San Juan Capistrano’: A Poem by Margaret Coats
  • ‘The Siege of Manor Castle’: A Poem by Paul A. Freeman
  • ‘Woodstock’ and Other Poems by Gerard Maritato
  • ‘Herodias on John the Baptist’: A Poem by Joseph S. Salemi
  • ‘If You’ve Ever Drowned’: A Poem by Katie Devine

Categories

  • Acrostic
  • Alexandroid
  • Alliterative
  • Art
  • Best Poems
  • Blank Verse
  • Chant Royal
  • Classical Poets Live
  • Clerihew
  • Covid-19
  • Deconstructing Communism
  • Educational
  • Epic
  • Epigrams and Proverbs
  • Essays
    • Interviews with Poets
    • Poetry Reviews
  • Featured
  • From the Society
  • Great Poets
    • Dante Alighieri
    • Edgar Allan Poe
    • Emily Dickinson
    • Geoffrey Chaucer
    • Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
    • Homer
    • John Keats
    • John Milton
    • Robert Frost
    • William Blake
    • William Shakespeare
    • William Wordsworth
  • Human Rights in China
  • Limerick
  • Love Poems
  • Music
  • Pantoum
  • Performing Arts
  • Poetry
    • Beauty
    • Children's Poems
    • Culture
    • Ekphrastic
    • Found Poems
    • High School Poets
    • Humor
    • Riddles
  • Poetry Challenge
  • Poetry Contests
  • Poetry Forms
    • Curtal Sonnet
    • Haiku
  • Poetry Readings
  • Rhupunt
  • Rondeau
  • Rondeau Redoublé
  • Rondel
  • Rubaiyat
  • Sapphic Verse
  • Satire
  • Science
  • Sestina
  • Shape Poems
  • Short Stories
  • Song Lyrics
  • Sonnet
  • Symposium
  • Terrorism
  • Terza Rima
  • The Environment
  • Translation
  • Triolet
  • Video
  • Villanelle

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Submit Poetry
  • Become a Member
  • Members List
  • Support the Society
  • Advertisement Placement
  • Comments Policy
  • Terms of Use

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Poems
    • Beauty
    • Culture
    • Satire
    • Humor
    • Children’s
    • Art
    • Ekphrastic
    • Epic
    • Epigrams and Proverbs
    • Human Rights in China
    • Music
    • Performing Arts
    • Riddles
    • Science
    • Song Lyrics
    • The Environment
    • The Raven
    • Found Poems
    • High School Poets
    • Terrorism
    • Covid-19
  • Poetry Forms
    • Sonnet
    • Haiku
    • Limerick
    • Villanelle
    • Rondeau
    • Pantoum
    • Sestina
    • Triolet
    • Acrostic
    • Alexandroid
    • Alliterative
    • Blank Verse
    • Chant Royal
    • Clerihew
    • Rhupunt
    • Rondeau Redoublé
    • Rondel
    • Rubaiyat
    • Sapphic Verse
    • Shape Poems
    • Terza Rima
  • Great Poets
    • Geoffrey Chaucer
    • Emily Dickinson
    • Homer
    • Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
    • Dante Alighieri
    • John Keats
    • John Milton
    • Edgar Allan Poe
    • William Shakespeare
    • William Wordsworth
    • William Blake
    • Robert Frost
  • Love Poems
  • Contests
  • SCP Academy
    • Educational
    • Teaching Classical Poetry—A Guide for Educators
    • Poetry Forms
    • The SCP Journal
    • Books

© 2025 SCP. WebDesign by CODEC Prime.