Agri-Horticultural Society of India flower show, by Biswarup Ganguly‘Choices’: A Poem by Shamik Banerjee The Society March 16, 2024 Beauty, Poetry 12 Comments . Choices Some lovers only give the rose, __Some only choose to take, Although the florist keeps a bunch __For every partner’s sake. The sun has risen for our town __And also for your city. While you say it’s a scalding morn, __We say it’s warm and pretty. The Lord is there for everyone. __He’s as much mine as yours. Yet, some receive Him when He knocks; __Some drive Him from their doors. . . Shamik Banerjee resides in Assam, India with his parents and works for a local firm. His poems have appeared in Fevers of the Mind, Lothlorien Poetry Journal, and Westward Quarterly, among others, and some of his poems are forthcoming in Dreich and The Ekstasis Review, to name a few. NOTE TO READERS: If you enjoyed this poem or other content, please consider making a donation to the Society of Classical Poets. The Society of Classical Poets does not endorse any views expressed in individual poems or commentary. 12 Responses Roy E. Peterson March 16, 2024 Shamik, such precious thoughts in a compact form. Beautifully done. Reply Shamik Banerjee March 16, 2024 I am glad you felt so, Mr. Peterson. Thank you so much for reading and commenting. Reply Phil S. Rogers March 16, 2024 A choice for everyone to make a life goes by quickly. Thank you, Shamik. Reply Shamik Banerjee March 16, 2024 Indeed, Phil. Thank you so much for taking the time to read and comment. Reply Joseph S. Salemi March 16, 2024 This is a beautiful little vignette of description combined with pious thought. I would suggest one small change. In the first quatrain, it is awkward to enjamb over to a single small monosyllable “It.” The problem could be resolved in this manner: Some only choose to take, [just add a comma at the end] Although the florist keeps a bunch [use “Although” instead of “Though”] There’s no need to use the word “It” at all, since the parallelism of “give” and “choose” in the first two lines makes it very clear that the object of the infinitive “to take” is the rose. Reply Shamik Banerjee March 16, 2024 Mr. Salemi, thank you so much for your appreciation of my poem. I fully agree with your suggestion. Omitting the “it” is removing the awkwardness while keeping the meaning intact. Thank you so much for this valuable guidance. Reply C.B. Anderson March 16, 2024 I also wondered, Shamik, whether the very last line should not have been: “Some drive Him from their doors.” Margaret Coats March 16, 2024 These are three profound reflections about kinds of choices that indicate attitudes toward life. Starting with the rose is a good beginning with a picture, and including the florist’s shop brings up a consideration I never thought of. My husband might like some daffodils, and they’ll be for sale soon. Reply Shamik Banerjee March 16, 2024 Dear Margaret, thank you so much for your thoughts on my poem, and I am so happy to know that it reminded you about the sale. Reply Shamik Banerjee March 17, 2024 Mr. Anderson, thank you so much reading and commenting. I agree with your point. Mike Bryant will make the change. Thank you again. Reply Susan Jarvis Bryant March 17, 2024 Shamik, this lovely poem has touched my heart with its message. It’s melodic flow and clarity result in a work of beauty. We might all do well to think very carefully before we choose… the outcome could change the world as we know it. Shamik, thank you! Reply Morrison Handley-Schachler March 18, 2024 This is a very neatly written poem, which expresses something very important. Thank you very much for writing this for us, Shamik. Reply Leave a Reply Cancel ReplyYour email address will not be published.CommentName* Email* Website Δ This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Roy E. Peterson March 16, 2024 Shamik, such precious thoughts in a compact form. Beautifully done. Reply
Shamik Banerjee March 16, 2024 I am glad you felt so, Mr. Peterson. Thank you so much for reading and commenting. Reply
Phil S. Rogers March 16, 2024 A choice for everyone to make a life goes by quickly. Thank you, Shamik. Reply
Shamik Banerjee March 16, 2024 Indeed, Phil. Thank you so much for taking the time to read and comment. Reply
Joseph S. Salemi March 16, 2024 This is a beautiful little vignette of description combined with pious thought. I would suggest one small change. In the first quatrain, it is awkward to enjamb over to a single small monosyllable “It.” The problem could be resolved in this manner: Some only choose to take, [just add a comma at the end] Although the florist keeps a bunch [use “Although” instead of “Though”] There’s no need to use the word “It” at all, since the parallelism of “give” and “choose” in the first two lines makes it very clear that the object of the infinitive “to take” is the rose. Reply
Shamik Banerjee March 16, 2024 Mr. Salemi, thank you so much for your appreciation of my poem. I fully agree with your suggestion. Omitting the “it” is removing the awkwardness while keeping the meaning intact. Thank you so much for this valuable guidance. Reply
C.B. Anderson March 16, 2024 I also wondered, Shamik, whether the very last line should not have been: “Some drive Him from their doors.”
Margaret Coats March 16, 2024 These are three profound reflections about kinds of choices that indicate attitudes toward life. Starting with the rose is a good beginning with a picture, and including the florist’s shop brings up a consideration I never thought of. My husband might like some daffodils, and they’ll be for sale soon. Reply
Shamik Banerjee March 16, 2024 Dear Margaret, thank you so much for your thoughts on my poem, and I am so happy to know that it reminded you about the sale. Reply
Shamik Banerjee March 17, 2024 Mr. Anderson, thank you so much reading and commenting. I agree with your point. Mike Bryant will make the change. Thank you again. Reply
Susan Jarvis Bryant March 17, 2024 Shamik, this lovely poem has touched my heart with its message. It’s melodic flow and clarity result in a work of beauty. We might all do well to think very carefully before we choose… the outcome could change the world as we know it. Shamik, thank you! Reply
Morrison Handley-Schachler March 18, 2024 This is a very neatly written poem, which expresses something very important. Thank you very much for writing this for us, Shamik. Reply