"Paschal Lamb" by Josefa de Óbidos ‘The Lamb’: A Poem for Good Friday by Phillip Whidden The Society March 28, 2024 Beauty, Culture, Poetry 26 Comments . The Lamb “And suddenly there was with the angel a heavenly host saying, Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace, goodwill toward men.” —Luke 2:14 The lamb looks up and sees a light, a star Or something heavenly, a highness like A lamb’s best dreams. He thinks he hears a far Off voice. The star is bladelike with a spike Gashing towards the lamb. This star is sharp Like winter air, more lance-like than the form Of icicles. A sound like breaking harp Strings pierces night-time. Voices spreading warm Across the hills speak something that the lamb Cannot discern. He snuggles up against His mother, baaas, “I will not be a ram.” He feels a threat, a menace, cold, condensed. ..The shepherds lead him to a shed. He sees ..A troubled scene. He stumbles to his knees. . . Phillip Whidden is an American living in England who has been published in America, England, Scotland (and elsewhere) in book form, online, and in journals. NOTE TO READERS: If you enjoyed this poem or other content, please consider making a donation to the Society of Classical Poets. The Society of Classical Poets does not endorse any views expressed in individual poems or commentary. Trending now: 26 Responses Gigi Ryan March 28, 2024 What a striking sonnet. Thank you. Reply Phillip Whidden March 28, 2024 Thank you for your positive response, Gigo Ryan. Reply Rohini March 28, 2024 This is sad, beautiful and deftly nuanced. Thank you. Reply Phillip Whidden March 28, 2024 Thank you for your deep reply, Rohini. Reply Cynthia Erlandson March 28, 2024 I like the way you’ve subtly juxtaposed Christ’s birth and death. The star “bladelike with a spike / Gashing towards the Lamb.” really pulls the two ends of the story together. Reply Phillip Whidden March 28, 2024 I’m pleased with your close reading, Cynthia Erlandson. Thank you. Reply Phillip Whidden March 28, 2024 Thank you very much, Gigi Ryan. Reply Shamik Banerjee March 28, 2024 This sonnet beautifully describes the Event, all from the viewpoint of the lamb with its terse closing couplet. I love the emphasis given on describing the star. I think this poem goes on to show that the innocent and pure of heart hear His “voice” or, at least, get some hint about His next plan. Thank you, Mr. Whidden, for this wonderful piece! Reply Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Thank you, Shamik Banerjee. You were generous to send such a thorough and insightful response. Reply Margaret Coats March 29, 2024 A touching presentation from the animal’s imagined point of view, leaving the reader to supply the connections with Jesus as Lamb of God. This necessarily makes the reading and proper interpretation a most thoughtful process. As well as the lamb compared to Jesus, and the star compared to instruments of the Passion, there is the temporal distance of Christmas and Good Friday, in the life of Christ, and as celebrated in each Christian year. A great deal to incorporate in a short poem, but all the finer is your achievement, Philip. Reply Margaret Coats March 29, 2024 And I agree with Shamik Banerjee, that historic and symbolic dimensions can lead further, into a devotional consideration by the reader seeking personal guidance toward a deeper relationship with God. Reply Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Margaret Coates, I think my unfinished reply got sent. Sorry. I’m touched by your intelligent and thorough response. You were kind to give so much consideration to the poem. I did not imagine you would read it as a devotional tool. Reply Susan Jarvis Bryant March 29, 2024 Phillip, I always revel in a poet’s ability to explore the known from an alternative and striking perspective, and your fine sonnet does just that. I love the symbolism. The imagery is wonderful, and the message is beautiful. Thank you! Reply Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Susan Jarvis Bryant, You praised just about every important aspect of the sonnet in your accolades. Yes, it is (so far as I know) a unique perspective on both the stories of the birth of Jesus and Good Friday. The symbolism is, of course, borrowed from the bibilical source so I can hardly lay claim to it for myself. I tried to avoid cliche in the imagery and hope I succeeded. The beauty in the poem is very much shadowed by horror. Maybe that contrast enlarges the beauty. Reply Joseph S. Salemi March 29, 2024 A strong detail in this sonnet is the linked enjambment of the first eleven lines. This flow of words then leads to the closure, where “threat,” “menace,” “cold,” and “troubled” all suggest the anticipated sacrifice. When he bleats “I will not be a ram,” we are getting prophecy from the mouth of an animal — something which the ancients would have understood as divine. Reply Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Joseph S. Salemi, I really liked all your very perspicacious readings and responses, not least the one about the ancients and animals as part of prophecy. The lamb in this instance seems to have received the prophecy from the angels and the star. A very perspicacious beast in the prophecy realm aligned with you in the close reading realm. Thank you very much. Reply Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 The system refuses to let me send my second comment. Report this to the editors? Reply Mike Bryant March 29, 2024 Phillip, you can write a new comment at the bottom of the entire thread or use the nearest reply button above what you would like to comment on. Thanks, Mike Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Thanks. I did click on the nearest button and it was that method that failed. Mike Bryant March 29, 2024 Phillip, you have just posted two comments of concern. Can you use the same method to post what you would like to say? Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 I tried to post a second reply to Joseph S. Salemi. The system said it was a repition of an earlier reply. I checked. The earlier reply that was supposedly being repeated was not there. Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 I just now tried to answer your message above. I wrote a completely new message. Your system said it was a repeat. Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 I checked to make sure that I had not tried to send the same message again. The claim that I had tried to send a repeated message was not borne out by the facts. The message that I was supposedly sending again was NOT in the string above the system’s claim that I was re-sending the same message. LATER, yes, I did see that the previous message had indeed been sent but that was not visible to me when I checked to see if it was there–and that therefore I was sending the same message again. For me this is a difficulty, but perhaps not for the Society of Classical Poets. Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 I checked to make sure that I had not tried to send the same message again. The claim that I had tried to send a repeated message was not borne out by the facts. The message that I was supposedly sending again was NOT in the string above the system’s claim that I was re-sending the same message. LATER, yes, I did see that the previous message had indeed been sent but that was not visible to me when I checked to see if it was there–and that therefore I was sending the same message again. For me this is a difficulty, but perhaps not for the Society of Classical Poets. Reply Mike Bryant March 29, 2024 Philip, this is a bug that happens occasionally. It is not an SCP problem, but a WordPress problem. Reply Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Thanks, Mike Bryant. Leave a Reply Cancel ReplyYour email address will not be published.CommentName* Email* Website Δ This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Cynthia Erlandson March 28, 2024 I like the way you’ve subtly juxtaposed Christ’s birth and death. The star “bladelike with a spike / Gashing towards the Lamb.” really pulls the two ends of the story together. Reply
Phillip Whidden March 28, 2024 I’m pleased with your close reading, Cynthia Erlandson. Thank you. Reply
Shamik Banerjee March 28, 2024 This sonnet beautifully describes the Event, all from the viewpoint of the lamb with its terse closing couplet. I love the emphasis given on describing the star. I think this poem goes on to show that the innocent and pure of heart hear His “voice” or, at least, get some hint about His next plan. Thank you, Mr. Whidden, for this wonderful piece! Reply
Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Thank you, Shamik Banerjee. You were generous to send such a thorough and insightful response. Reply
Margaret Coats March 29, 2024 A touching presentation from the animal’s imagined point of view, leaving the reader to supply the connections with Jesus as Lamb of God. This necessarily makes the reading and proper interpretation a most thoughtful process. As well as the lamb compared to Jesus, and the star compared to instruments of the Passion, there is the temporal distance of Christmas and Good Friday, in the life of Christ, and as celebrated in each Christian year. A great deal to incorporate in a short poem, but all the finer is your achievement, Philip. Reply
Margaret Coats March 29, 2024 And I agree with Shamik Banerjee, that historic and symbolic dimensions can lead further, into a devotional consideration by the reader seeking personal guidance toward a deeper relationship with God. Reply
Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Margaret Coates, I think my unfinished reply got sent. Sorry. I’m touched by your intelligent and thorough response. You were kind to give so much consideration to the poem. I did not imagine you would read it as a devotional tool. Reply
Susan Jarvis Bryant March 29, 2024 Phillip, I always revel in a poet’s ability to explore the known from an alternative and striking perspective, and your fine sonnet does just that. I love the symbolism. The imagery is wonderful, and the message is beautiful. Thank you! Reply
Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Susan Jarvis Bryant, You praised just about every important aspect of the sonnet in your accolades. Yes, it is (so far as I know) a unique perspective on both the stories of the birth of Jesus and Good Friday. The symbolism is, of course, borrowed from the bibilical source so I can hardly lay claim to it for myself. I tried to avoid cliche in the imagery and hope I succeeded. The beauty in the poem is very much shadowed by horror. Maybe that contrast enlarges the beauty. Reply
Joseph S. Salemi March 29, 2024 A strong detail in this sonnet is the linked enjambment of the first eleven lines. This flow of words then leads to the closure, where “threat,” “menace,” “cold,” and “troubled” all suggest the anticipated sacrifice. When he bleats “I will not be a ram,” we are getting prophecy from the mouth of an animal — something which the ancients would have understood as divine. Reply
Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Joseph S. Salemi, I really liked all your very perspicacious readings and responses, not least the one about the ancients and animals as part of prophecy. The lamb in this instance seems to have received the prophecy from the angels and the star. A very perspicacious beast in the prophecy realm aligned with you in the close reading realm. Thank you very much. Reply
Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 The system refuses to let me send my second comment. Report this to the editors? Reply
Mike Bryant March 29, 2024 Phillip, you can write a new comment at the bottom of the entire thread or use the nearest reply button above what you would like to comment on. Thanks, Mike
Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 Thanks. I did click on the nearest button and it was that method that failed.
Mike Bryant March 29, 2024 Phillip, you have just posted two comments of concern. Can you use the same method to post what you would like to say?
Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 I tried to post a second reply to Joseph S. Salemi. The system said it was a repition of an earlier reply. I checked. The earlier reply that was supposedly being repeated was not there.
Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 I just now tried to answer your message above. I wrote a completely new message. Your system said it was a repeat.
Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 I checked to make sure that I had not tried to send the same message again. The claim that I had tried to send a repeated message was not borne out by the facts. The message that I was supposedly sending again was NOT in the string above the system’s claim that I was re-sending the same message. LATER, yes, I did see that the previous message had indeed been sent but that was not visible to me when I checked to see if it was there–and that therefore I was sending the same message again. For me this is a difficulty, but perhaps not for the Society of Classical Poets.
Phillip Whidden March 29, 2024 I checked to make sure that I had not tried to send the same message again. The claim that I had tried to send a repeated message was not borne out by the facts. The message that I was supposedly sending again was NOT in the string above the system’s claim that I was re-sending the same message. LATER, yes, I did see that the previous message had indeed been sent but that was not visible to me when I checked to see if it was there–and that therefore I was sending the same message again. For me this is a difficulty, but perhaps not for the Society of Classical Poets. Reply
Mike Bryant March 29, 2024 Philip, this is a bug that happens occasionally. It is not an SCP problem, but a WordPress problem. Reply