"Twilight in the Wilderness" by Frederic Edwin Church‘America the Beautiful’ by James A. Tweedie The Society July 4, 2018 Beauty, Culture, Poetry, Popular Poetry Archives 22 Comments Poet’s Note: I wrote this poem in the same metrical form as the song “America the Beautiful” (but without the internal rhyme). You can sing it if you want, but I think it is most effective when simply read out loud. This year our nation’s birthday seems a tad bit more subdued, As people from the Right and Left intensify their feud. Progressives and Conservatives refuse to compromise On anything that matters to us ordinary guys. I’m skewered from the Left for being White and middle class, I’m skewered from the Right for criticizing Trump as crass. Republicans and Democrats each want me on their side. “We’re right!” “They’re wrong.” “Don’t be a fool!” “They’re bad!” We’re good!” “Decide!” To tell the truth, I find this demonizing tiresome. Why can’t we all just get along? The anger leaves me numb. So, as I sit and watch the late-night fireworks display, I think of all the things our nation celebrates this day. Our liberty and freedom, our pursuit of happiness, Endowed by our Creator, we enjoy much blessedness. I ponder immigration and the problems that we face As millions seek to grab a piece of that which we embrace. I find it hard to blame them, after all, what we have got Is something my ancestors also hungered for and sought. But what to do? Just let them in? Or build a border wall? While pledging liberty and justice just for us? Or all? A problem? Yes! But one I’m very gratified to see, For it just goes to prove we’re still the land of liberty. How sad to be a country where nobody wants to go. A place like Myanmar, or Syria, or Mexico. Who stands in line or risks their life to enter North Korea? Who from North Africa is clamoring for the Crimea? Let Russia host the World Cup, a grandiose affair. But note that athletes won’t be seeking safe asylum there. Consider Cuba, Libya, and other places hateful. And then look at the U.S.A. and be forever grateful. Our nation is not perfect, we critique its every flaw, While striving for equality in justice and in law. I wish the folks in Washington who wield so much clout Would just for once stop shouting and declare a brief time-out To reach across the aisle in unfeigned humility And sing in perfect unison, “My Country, ‘tis of Thee.” All problems have solutions, but to find them we must try To search for them together, “Them” and “Us” and “You” and “I.” But even as we argue and debate what should be done There’s something that transcends our bickering and makes us one. We want our nation to become the best that it can be— A place of hope for “huddled masses yearning to breathe free.” So, on this blessed Fourth let us give thanks for liberty. America the beautiful, God shed his grace on thee! James A. Tweedie is a recently retired pastor living in Long Beach, Washington. He likes to walk on the beach with his wife. He has written and self-published four novels and a collection of short stories. He has several hundred unpublished poems tucked away in drawers. NOTE: The Society considers this page, where your poetry resides, to be your residence as well, where you may invite family, friends, and others to visit. Feel free to treat this page as your home and remove anyone here who disrespects you. Simply send an email to email@example.com. Put “Remove Comment” in the subject line and list which comments you would like removed. The Society does not endorse any views expressed in individual poems or comments and reserves the right to remove any comments to maintain the decorum of this website and the integrity of the Society. Please see our Comments Policy here. Share this:Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Click to print (Opens in new window)Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) 22 Responses Amy Foreman July 4, 2018 Leo, As a mother whose kids read the poetry and comments on this site, I ask that you hold the vulgarity. If your commentary must include crude references to anatomy, then it might be better left unsaid. Surely you can keep a civil tongue and still elucidate your point. I have recommended this site to others who enjoy poetry, and we would all do well to remember that those of us who publish and comment here are representing the SCP. Let us not foul it with unnecessary indecency. Reply Leo Yankevich July 4, 2018 Amy Foreman, Where is there vulgarity? (Grow a pair? lol) Again, you confuse middle class (bourgeoisie) morality/ethics with the love of God. Surely you can mind your own business, at least for once? You have a typical school-marm mentality typical of bible-belt Americans. Reply Amy Foreman July 4, 2018 Hmmm . . . let’s see . . . , If I WERE your Bible-belt school-marm (smile), your “penalty” for using crude language in class would be to write Proverbs 15:4 on the blackboard, 10 times, in your neatest cursive: A wholesome tongue is a tree of life: but perverseness therein is a breach in the spirit. 😉 Reply Leo Yankevich July 4, 2018 Amy, I am a Roman Catholic, not a heretic like you. Again, you confuse prudery with morality. I find your attempts at poetry perverse, Amy, with their thumping laughable plaints about morality. There is so much frustration in your work and so little skill. Why so? Whence the bitterness? Perhaps it has its roots in primordial evil? Reply E. V. July 4, 2018 Leo, you may be a brilliant poet, but perhaps your social skills could benefit from a little tweaking. You do realize you’ve crossed lines that shouldn’t be crossed? Don’t miss your cue to apologize to sweet Amy, whose lovely poetry we adore. Now let’s get on with enjoying the 4th! Reply Leo Yankevich July 4, 2018 E.V.– What have social skills to do with truth? Amy is not a very good poet and neither are you. In fact, you are both very bad. You can applaud one another, but that changes nothing. Amy ought to apologize to me. I don’t apologize to poetastresses who stick their noses where they don’t belong and who accuse me of vulgarity, which of course is a mere projection of their own sullied souls. Reply E. V. July 4, 2018 What do social skills and truth have in common? Neither was present in your above comments. Amy is already an accomplished poet. As for your assessment that my poetry is “very bad”, one day I’ll quote you on it. Thanks for the laugh. E. V. July 4, 2018 James, your poem has nice rhymes and a good flow. A lot of people, myself included, agree with the message that we are forgetting how to bridge our differences and come together as Americans. Your poem has an important message. Reply James A. Tweedie July 4, 2018 Leo, The word “doggerel” is a big vague. If you are referring to the meter, it isn’t doggerel. If you are referring to the rhyming scheme. It isn’t doggerel. If you are referring to lightweight comedic content, it isn’t doggerel. If you referring to subject content (i.e. philosophical concepts of liberty, freedom, unalienable rights endowed by a Creator, flash-point issues of immigration and border security, national identity, civility and incivility in public and political discourse, and the like) then I would submit that the subject matter is non-trivial and therefore does not fall into the category of doggerel. If, however, you are critiquing the poem on its approach to these matters and you do not agree with them, that is an entirely different matter, but to dismiss my thoughts with the intentionally demeaning label, “doggerel,” falls to the level of either crass bullying or the admission that you are incapable of engaging in a reasoned conversation with the author. Leo, I know you to be an intelligent man and an ardent, talented, and inspired poet and translator. I respect you for all of this. I do not, however, find your comments to be either helpful, articulate, or particularly erudite. Your comments regarding my faith (of which you know nothing), my character (of which you know nothing), and my vocation as a Protestant Christian pastor (which you derisively mock) border on bigotry. I am also confused as to why you are so passionate about testicles? If this site is devoted to poetry, then I suggest that we discuss poetry and forswear making specious personal attacks against one another. Reply Leo Yankevich July 4, 2018 Tweedie, I am referring to the inferior quality of your verses, not to their metre. (Doggerel has more than one meaning.) I am not here to help you, as you will never get any better as a poet than you are now (pretty lousy). Poetry is a jungle, a boxing match, not a bingo game, or group therapy. Amy, Tweedie mentioned “testicles”; I never did. Moralize to him! He’s even one of “your” preachers. I know exactly what your faith is, Tweedie, libtardism. Reply Dave Whippman July 5, 2018 Isn’t there room for all types of poetry? Of course, which kind you prefer is up to you. But Ogden Nash, for example, wrote plenty of stuff that was neither “a jungle or a boxing match” and he is pretty highly regarded. J. Simon Harris July 4, 2018 Mr. Tweedie, thank you for this patriotic poem on Independence Day. The basic sentiment of the poem is much needed in America today: the divisiveness is more damning than any of the issues our country is so divided over. Meanwhile the politicians and other powerful people profit from the schism, at our expense. It is possible to love your neighbor whose political beliefs, religious beliefs, even moral beliefs, are different from your own. It is possible to hear people out even though you vehemently disagree with them. It is possible to see a perspective that’s not your own, and understand it without endorsing it. We don’t have to be dragged along by the vitriol of the loudest voices, the most violent voices. We don’t have to let the politicians and the media polarize us. We are Americans. Our bond of common freedom is stronger than the issues of our time. Let us speak to one another, listen to one another, love one another despite our different views. Let fear not overpower compassion. Let us celebrate our nation today as brothers and sisters. Thank you for this poem, and God bless America. Reply Amy Foreman July 5, 2018 Well put, J. Simon. Reply James A. Tweedie July 5, 2018 What Amy said, to which I will only add the words, “Thank you.” Dave Whippman July 5, 2018 I thought it was a cleverly-written poem that made some good points. ironically, the comments debate with Mr Yankevich seems an example of how debate is becoming more personal and less courteous. Reply E.V. July 5, 2018 That’s a very astute observation. Thank you. Reply Leo Yankevich July 5, 2018 Well, I admit I made some strong counter punches (regarding evil), but I am like Trump in that way. For that I apologize, but I stand by my opinion of this poem and its message, as well my opinion of both Amy and E.V. as aspiring poets. Amy is, of course, much better than E.V., but both will find serious publication difficult, and this is not my fault. Bad boxers are called “tomato cans,” bad baseball players “bums,” and bad poets. . . “poetasters.” Perhaps a gradual evolution of these two poetesses is possible, but I have my doubts. Reply David Paul Behrens July 5, 2018 Mr. Tweedie, this poem is topical, thoughtful, enjoyable to read and perfect for the Fourth of July. Thank you. Reply James Sale July 6, 2018 Hi James, I really enjoyed this poem and for me the most important thing is the spirit of it which in the UK is almost inconceivable: that is to say, overt patriotism and pride in one’s country is seen as little-Britain, anti-European, almost racist’ by the left-wing intelligentsia who dominate our discourse. I really love England but to write a poem like this would be impossible for me, since the whole way we frame things is so different. So well done: I like this national call-to-arms and reversion to the founding principles which undoubtedly made America great. Stirring stuff. Reply James A. Tweedie July 6, 2018 James, Our immigration debate (and the circumstances surrounding it) is quite different than the one you are having in Europe and the UK, and in any case, where or why would you build a wall? . . . unless, of course, you felt the need to defend yourselves from us pesky Scots, a la Hadrian! My poem is very contextualized in both time and place and would be difficult to translate into any other international setting. I suppose Leo could probably pull it off but I suspect the end result would not look very much like the original. By the way, Leo, if you are reading this please know that I wish you well. Reply Leo Yankevich July 6, 2018 Tweedie, Well, at least we know where you stand; on the right side!:) Reply Leave a Reply Cancel ReplyYour email address will not be published.CommentName* Email* Website Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Notify me of new posts by email. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.