Photo of failed attempt to fell an Andrew Jackson statue in Washington, DC‘When the Statues Were Felled,’ a Rondeau Redoublé by Brian Yapko The Society June 21, 2021 Culture, Poetry, Rondeau Redoublé 32 Comments . When the statues were felled the crass multitude cheered. Historians wept while the rioters yelled. Society crumbled. Debate disappeared. Where fraud gorged on Truth only anarchy dwelled. The protests unprincipled radicals held Preached self-loathing dogma to which they adhered With threats we must join them, by choice or compelled. When the statues were felled the crass multitude cheered. Our best minds surrendered. I know what they feared: The pitchforks and torches; the slander propelled By those who let justice and truth be veneered. Historians wept while the rioters yelled. Culture was cancelled. Civility quelled. The mob mocked what patriots loved and revered, Though honor disparaged could not be dispelled! Society crumbled. Debate disappeared. Icons were smashed as the nihilists leered. But our spirits are safe—that’s where courage is held; Our anger is just and our blindness has cleared! Where fraud gorged on Truth only anarchy dwelled. But we can prevail if we’re truly impelled To stand up to bullies despite being smeared. This hatred of history must be repelled! The future must know righteous men persevered When the statues were felled. . . Brian Yapko is a lawyer who also writes poetry. He lives in Santa Fe, New Mexico. NOTE: The Society considers this page, where your poetry resides, to be your residence as well, where you may invite family, friends, and others to visit. Feel free to treat this page as your home and remove anyone here who disrespects you. Simply send an email to firstname.lastname@example.org. Put “Remove Comment” in the subject line and list which comments you would like removed. The Society does not endorse any views expressed in individual poems or comments and reserves the right to remove any comments to maintain the decorum of this website and the integrity of the Society. Please see our Comments Policy here. Share this:Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Click to print (Opens in new window)Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) 32 Responses Cynthia Erlandson June 21, 2021 This is SO GOOD! Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 21, 2021 Thank you, Cynthia! I’m excited that you liked it! Reply Daniel Kemper June 21, 2021 I just love this structurally; the intertwining folds are great. They support the sound so nicely, whether or not pursued intellectually for the pattern. But the poem rewards both. I’ll be back to savor it again! Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 21, 2021 Thank you, Daniel. The form is so tricky, so I’m very pleased that you think my attempt works. For me, the idea behind the pattern was the building up of an endless cycle of culture and history being senselessly attacked. Again. Reply Julian D. Woodruff June 21, 2021 A triumph of skill and persuasiveness, Brian. It’s impressive that having decided to repeat the root “-pell,” you found a place for 5 (=all, I think) of its prefixes. Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 21, 2021 Thank you, Julian. The message here came from the heart — something that has deeply troubled me since these cancel cultures riots started last year. Thanks for noting the “-pell” root words. My use of all prefixes was completely unintentional but it’s especially pleasing to have that pointed out to me. I learn things about my own poems here that I never fully grasp when writing them! Reply Tonia June 21, 2021 “Where fraud gorged on Truth only anarchy dwelled”: This is my favorite line of your wonderful work.__ Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 21, 2021 Thank you so much, Tonia. I rewrote that line multiple times. It was probably the hardest one to get right so I’m very pleased my efforts payed off! Reply Sally Cook June 21, 2021 Great! Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 21, 2021 Thank you so much, Sally! Reply Margaret Coats June 21, 2021 Brian, this is a powerful use of both form and meter to address this vital topic. The rondeau redouble texte (first stanza) states the issue with compressed force, as Tonia acknowledges in her appreciation of its final line. Then you approach the topic in four meaningfully different ways, and conclude with a battle cry stanza. Anapestic meter is regular in the first line, but you begin most other lines with an iamb. These bracing starts become unexpectedly forceful when the fourth and fifth stanzas begin with headless iambs (a single stressed syllable as the first foot of a line). They function like a commander’s encouraging shouts when the fight has been long. All in all, it’s a fine military reveille (wake-up), returning to fully regular anapests only in the final repetition, where readers can look forward to the battle being over and won. This is personally heartening to me, as just yesterday a priest was cancelled from my local parish by the reading of a letter from a cowardly bishop, who tried to blame the expulsion on the priest’s religious superior in another diocese. The priest had given a sermon describing the signs that the unseen Holy Spirit is present, and applying this to church and state, where the opposite signs are present. He named big names, and not only was the offending livestream sermon removed from the parish website, but also every other sermon the priest had made. We do know that, given an opportunity to explain himself, the priest retracted nothing. Bravo, Father Francis! Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 21, 2021 Thank you very much, Margaret! Your explication of my meter gives me more credit than I deserve. I know I wanted to build and keep building until a reactionary emotional outburst became inevitable but I didn’t know precisely how I was achieving this metrically until you analyzed it for me. I certainly look forward to this battle being over and won! I’m so sorry about the situation at your local parish. I am deeply tired of gutlessness in the face of cancel culture. To paraphrase the old adage (Edmund Burke? John Stuart Mill?) the only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good people to do nothing. I hope your priest gets uncancelled — and soon. And I can’t wait for cancel culture to enter the dustbin of history along with the Cultural Revolution, the Bolshevik Revolution and all the other historical seizures that have tried to destroy or rewrite history. Reply Margaret Coats June 23, 2021 Brian, this is the way Father Francis Gloudeman expressed it in his canceled sermon: “Nazi Germany would have never happened with just a few wicked men in high places. The only way that could happen was having a bunch of yes-men. Don’t question, just look out for yourself.” Mike, thanks for doing the search. These priests who preach the truth of the Gospel are being treated the way criminally abusive priests never were. Now we know what bishops are capable of, and that’s a real sign the Holy Spirit is not working in most of them. Mike Bryant June 22, 2021 Brian, this is a very fine rondeau redouble. Definitely blazing. And Margaret I did a search on DuckDuckGo because of your story of Father Francis: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=catholic+priest+canceled&t=ipad&ia=web It’s much worse than I would have guessed. Reply Brian Yapko June 22, 2021 Thank you, Mike! All aspects of cancel culture are just awful! BRIAN YAPKO June 23, 2021 Margaret, thank you for the link to your priest’s sermon. It really is painful to see someone who tries hard to be a good shepherd being cancelled because of being on the wrong side of political popularity. You know my private views on some of these points and my personal interest. But, since I triage my relationship with God above all other things, any such personal interest is secondary. I overwhelmingly believe that the freedom to speak out is precious, as is the freedom to disagree in a respectful debate. One should not lose a job over presenting one’s well-reasoned views — especially when one is trying to provide good leadership on all-important issues of moral clarity. Reply Margaret Coats June 23, 2021 Superb answer, my friend. Paul Freeman June 21, 2021 Just when I’m getting to grips with the rondeau, we have the rondeau redouble. Certainly a hot topic, dating from the mob pulling down George III’s statue at Bowling Green. There is a poem on the same theme on the SCP website: https://classicalpoets.org/2015/07/25/heritage-not-hate-and-other-poetry-by-james-huss/ Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 21, 2021 Paul — yes, an interesting form which is very tricky! Thanks for checking in on this poem and for placing it in historical context. I’ll check out the poem that you referred me to. Thank you! Reply Margaret Coats June 23, 2021 There are many SCP poems of more immediate relevance to Brian’s topic. Just search “statues” in our own SCP search bar, top right above the “Trending Poems.” Some of the results are not about cancel culture, but it’s surprising how many are. Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 23, 2021 Thank you, Margaret. I look forward to seeing how other poets have covered this subject. Sandi June 21, 2021 Brian, you are one of my favorite poets here, and this poem is exceptional on many levels. The form alone is a difficult one that I have never attempted-well done. Your rhyme and meter are always pleasing to the ear, and you address the insanity of the world with a bang. Perhaps you can write a poem about the new statues we have to take their place, like the 700-pound bronze statue of G.F. A true heroic role model for all our children to admire and emulate. Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 21, 2021 Thank you for your very kind comment! I’m so grateful that you like my work! This particular poem was indeed a difficult form. This was my first attempt and it really took a lot of nipping and tucking! I’m also glad that you appreciate what I’m trying to say in these challenging times. As for your proposed G.F. poem — a brilliant idea which, however, I think may be better suited to another poet — perhaps one who likes chaotic contemporary forms in which rhyme, meter, structure and message really don’t matter so long as it’s loud and demands attention. Reply Susan Jarvis Bryant June 21, 2021 Bravo Brian! I love everything about this poem – the form (one of my favorites), the adept execution, the message, and the passion and panache with which you deliver it. You are a poet after my own heart and I applaud your talent and your decision to blaze instead of bleat! An absolute treat! Thank you! Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 21, 2021 Thank you, Susan! No, you’re a poet after my heart! Whether you know it or not, I consider you an important mentor. Your poetry never fails to move me and I always find something new to learn from your obviously God-given skill at the use of form, meter, language, tone and — perhaps most importantly — your extremely good taste. If you hadn’t challenged me to try my hand at a rondeau a few months back, I would never have attempted this. And, of course, I have your brilliant rondeaux to inspire me. As for the subject matter, yes… thank you. I can’t stand being around the “sheeple” who bleat and accept and apologize and whine and who abdicate responsibility again and again. You, on the other hand, are an incredibly brave poet who has taken risks on very challenging subjects and I respect that tremendously. If I’m blazing, it’s largely because you’ve paved the way. So thank you. Reply C.B. Anderson June 22, 2021 You did a great job with an especially demanding fixed form, and the content was handled adeptly, without any hitches, weak lines or wrenched syntax. Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 22, 2021 Thank you very much, C.B. I am always grateful for your input! Reply David Watt June 23, 2021 The underlying form, although demanding, is unnoticed because the content is clear and strong. Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 23, 2021 Thank you, David. I appreciate that! Reply James Sale June 23, 2021 Brian, this is a tour-de-force of a poem, exceedingly technically adept; and it is your mind speaking with a full and ready force. As an aside, as good as this is, I prefer it when I hear your soul communicating with itself: you know when that is, don’t you? It’s when Prospero is on that island and magic happens. Know what I mean? Reply BRIAN YAPKO June 23, 2021 James, thank you very much for the compliment and thank you for the words of caution. Yes, I know exactly what you mean. To run with your Tempest metaphor, my most meaningful work is definitely written when I’m on that island and engaging with my soul. Sadly, my rather long history as a lawyer means that I default into zealous advocacy perhaps more often than is restful. But rest assured, getting up on a soap box like this is more the exception than the rule! Reply James Sale June 23, 2021 Spoken like a true poet, Brian! Write on! Leave a Reply Cancel ReplyYour email address will not be published.CommentName* Email* Website Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Notify me of new posts by email. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.