"Dream of Solomon" by Luca Giordano‘Life Is a Dream’ by Pedro Calderón de la Barca, Translated by Elwin Wirkala The Society June 28, 2022 Beauty, Poetry, Translation 6 Comments . Life Is a Dream by Pedro Calderón de la Barca (1600-1681) Translated by Elwin Wirkala The king dreams he is king, and lives with this deception ordering, disposing of and governing, and all the applauses he receives are but a loan writ on the wind and burnt to ashes in the end by death itself (what rotten luck!); to try to rule’s a waste of breath, since all will see themselves wake up at last within the dream of death! The rich man dreams of riches he is offered for a weight of care; paupers dream the fate they bear their misery, their poverty; others dream they’re set to win, strivers dream of toil’s end, some who dream aggrieve, offend, and through the world, in conclusion, all are dreaming self-delusion no one seems to comprehend. I dream that I in prison lie burdened with a prisoner’s fate, and then I dreamed another state and saw myself more lionized. What is life? A frenesy. What is life? Illusory, shadow ’tis, fiction, it, its greatest good not worth a whit, since all this life of ours seems but a dream, and dreams… are dreams. . . Original Spanish La vida es sueño Sueña el rey que es rey, y vive con este engaño mandando, disponiendo y gobernando; y este aplauso que recibe prestado, en el viento escribe, y en cenizas le convierte la muerte (¡desdicha fuerte!); ¡que hay quien intente reinar, viendo que ha de despertar en el sueño de la muerte! Sueña el rico en su riqueza que más cuidados le ofrece; sueña el pobre que padece su miseria y su pobreza; sueña el que a medrar empieza, sueña el que afana y pretende, sueña el que agravia y ofende; y en el mundo, en conclusión, todos sueñan lo que son, aunque ninguno lo entiende. Yo sueño que estoy aquí destas prisiones cargado, y soñé que en otro estado más lisonjero me vi. ¿Qué es la vida? Un frenesí. ¿Qué es la vida? Una ilusión, una sombra, una ficción, y el mayor bien es pequeño; que toda la vida es sueño, y los sueños, sueños son. . . Elwin Wirkala was in the Peace Corps in his early twenties and subsequently spent two plus decades in South America, gaining near native fluency in Portuguese and Spanish. He has translated Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz’s sonnets and the great Primer Sueño, on which he is writing a book. NOTE TO READERS: If you enjoyed this poem or other content, please consider making a donation to the Society of Classical Poets. The Society of Classical Poets does not endorse any views expressed in individual poems or commentary. Share this:Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Click to print (Opens in new window)Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)Trending now: 6 Responses Michael Pietrack June 28, 2022 “all the applauses he receives are but a loan writ on the wind and burnt to ashes in the end by death itself” This touched me. A timely message. Thank you. It reminded me of Ecclesiastes 2:11. Reply Elwin Wirkala July 2, 2022 Thank you for this reminder of Ecclesiastes 2:11, Michael. I often have Ecclesiastes in mind when translating from the Spanish Golden Age and other transcendentally-minded poets. Reply DONALD PETER McCRORY June 28, 2022 A very timely reminder of what human existence is for countless millions, as much in the past as for us alive today. So a very warm-hearted thanks for your rendering of a very famous passage in La Vida es Sueño. Translation is a very difficult art, very time-consuming and all too often casually dismissed. Amid the world´s woes of today, how good to listen to the voice of a master of verse talking to us of real and lasting values! My only question concerns the final lines: Calderon does not say ´´since all this life “seems” but a dream (he confirms it is a dream) and I wonder if the final line ¨and dreams .. are dreams could somewhow be strengthened? These are minor points and many readers , especially those who have read Golden Age Spanish Literature, will be delighted with your rendition. Thank you once again! Reply Elwin Wirkala July 2, 2022 Thank you for this kind comment, Donald. Your point is well taken. I couldn’t find a way to avoid ‘seems’ because of the rhyme with ‘dreams’, and also, in the Spanish Golden Age the powerful presence of the Arabic and Berber dispensation of eight plus earlier centuries remained. Asín Palacios writes of that period, with the great Sufic thinkers and poets like Ibn-Masarra and Ibn el-Arabi. Their main point from the Perennial Philosophic point of view (as per Aldous Huxley’s title of that name) is that people are basically upside-down in relation to reality. I owe that point mainly to Idries Shah who has a chapter on Palacios’ discoveries in The Sufis. The idea is that a greater reality exists and we can access it through philosophical study, whether Sufic or one of the other mystic schools. This is always in tension with credal institutions. As Barth said, mystics basically abolish institution and priesthood on their way to salvation. So ordinary life is a dream, and only seems to be reality. It’s Christ’s ‘Let the dead bury their dead’ and so on. Evan kindly mentions my translation of Sor Juana’s First Dream…it’s basically on the same topic: why we think everyday reality is experienced as anything but a dream. Poets intuit it, as did Emily D. with her ‘There is another loneliness’, or Rosalía de Castro with her ‘I don’t know what I’m eternally seeking/it’s something I lost I don’t know where’…well this probably sounds terribly pedantic. I’d like to hear more from you on this, Donald. Thank you for your kind words. Oh, in case this wasn’t clear: the Golden Age poets were so keenly aware of this ‘other dimension’, and I think it mined the true ore and put the gold into their age. Nowadays, iron pyrite seems to reign supreme, alas. Reply DONALD PETER McCRORY July 3, 2022 Thank you very much Elwin for your reply. I look forward to your next publication. Now retired I was a so-called Cervantista ( my biography of Cervantes entitled No Ordinary Man was relatively successful ( published by Peter Owen) and translated into Dutch and Mandarin; finally the copyrights were bought by an American company. My doctorate was on JORGE GUILLEN ( CANTICO) so I had a foot in two camps! Guillen ´s work is so refreshingly positive, buoyant and life-affirming and needs to be studied much more. I am a buddhist and so follow a teaching that looks at reality, morality and at current attitudes that perhaps, somehow, Calderon shared? ¿Quien sabe? On a different note is it not a great pity that Spain has no great classical theatre tradition that we have in the UK with the Royal Shakespeare Company in Stratford? How many of us who have studied G:Age drama have seen productions? Very few! Thanks once again and keep translating G.Age works! Karis January 20, 2024 Wow! This is so cool:) Thank you for translating. We recently discovered an old love letter from an admirer to a grandparent, and were translating what the admirer wanted to say… He quoted the first stanza of this poem (among other things). Awesome translation! Reply Leave a Reply Cancel ReplyYour email address will not be published.CommentName* Email* Website Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Notify me of new posts by email. Δ This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Michael Pietrack June 28, 2022 “all the applauses he receives are but a loan writ on the wind and burnt to ashes in the end by death itself” This touched me. A timely message. Thank you. It reminded me of Ecclesiastes 2:11. Reply
Elwin Wirkala July 2, 2022 Thank you for this reminder of Ecclesiastes 2:11, Michael. I often have Ecclesiastes in mind when translating from the Spanish Golden Age and other transcendentally-minded poets. Reply
DONALD PETER McCRORY June 28, 2022 A very timely reminder of what human existence is for countless millions, as much in the past as for us alive today. So a very warm-hearted thanks for your rendering of a very famous passage in La Vida es Sueño. Translation is a very difficult art, very time-consuming and all too often casually dismissed. Amid the world´s woes of today, how good to listen to the voice of a master of verse talking to us of real and lasting values! My only question concerns the final lines: Calderon does not say ´´since all this life “seems” but a dream (he confirms it is a dream) and I wonder if the final line ¨and dreams .. are dreams could somewhow be strengthened? These are minor points and many readers , especially those who have read Golden Age Spanish Literature, will be delighted with your rendition. Thank you once again! Reply
Elwin Wirkala July 2, 2022 Thank you for this kind comment, Donald. Your point is well taken. I couldn’t find a way to avoid ‘seems’ because of the rhyme with ‘dreams’, and also, in the Spanish Golden Age the powerful presence of the Arabic and Berber dispensation of eight plus earlier centuries remained. Asín Palacios writes of that period, with the great Sufic thinkers and poets like Ibn-Masarra and Ibn el-Arabi. Their main point from the Perennial Philosophic point of view (as per Aldous Huxley’s title of that name) is that people are basically upside-down in relation to reality. I owe that point mainly to Idries Shah who has a chapter on Palacios’ discoveries in The Sufis. The idea is that a greater reality exists and we can access it through philosophical study, whether Sufic or one of the other mystic schools. This is always in tension with credal institutions. As Barth said, mystics basically abolish institution and priesthood on their way to salvation. So ordinary life is a dream, and only seems to be reality. It’s Christ’s ‘Let the dead bury their dead’ and so on. Evan kindly mentions my translation of Sor Juana’s First Dream…it’s basically on the same topic: why we think everyday reality is experienced as anything but a dream. Poets intuit it, as did Emily D. with her ‘There is another loneliness’, or Rosalía de Castro with her ‘I don’t know what I’m eternally seeking/it’s something I lost I don’t know where’…well this probably sounds terribly pedantic. I’d like to hear more from you on this, Donald. Thank you for your kind words. Oh, in case this wasn’t clear: the Golden Age poets were so keenly aware of this ‘other dimension’, and I think it mined the true ore and put the gold into their age. Nowadays, iron pyrite seems to reign supreme, alas. Reply
DONALD PETER McCRORY July 3, 2022 Thank you very much Elwin for your reply. I look forward to your next publication. Now retired I was a so-called Cervantista ( my biography of Cervantes entitled No Ordinary Man was relatively successful ( published by Peter Owen) and translated into Dutch and Mandarin; finally the copyrights were bought by an American company. My doctorate was on JORGE GUILLEN ( CANTICO) so I had a foot in two camps! Guillen ´s work is so refreshingly positive, buoyant and life-affirming and needs to be studied much more. I am a buddhist and so follow a teaching that looks at reality, morality and at current attitudes that perhaps, somehow, Calderon shared? ¿Quien sabe? On a different note is it not a great pity that Spain has no great classical theatre tradition that we have in the UK with the Royal Shakespeare Company in Stratford? How many of us who have studied G:Age drama have seen productions? Very few! Thanks once again and keep translating G.Age works!
Karis January 20, 2024 Wow! This is so cool:) Thank you for translating. We recently discovered an old love letter from an admirer to a grandparent, and were translating what the admirer wanted to say… He quoted the first stanza of this poem (among other things). Awesome translation! Reply
