"The Expulsion of Adam and Eve from Paradise" by Benjamin West‘Cain’s Daughter’: A Poem by Patricia Rogers Crozier The Society May 22, 2023 Culture, Poetry 13 Comments . Cain’s Daughter I was not in the garden when the veil of beauty tore I heard no serpent beckon to me through the orchard door I weep no tears beholding the angel’s flaming sword For I never breathed the jasmine in the garden of the Lord. I did not walk in Eden at the splendid Dawn of Days I never heard His footsteps through shady ivy maze Many are the stories of that time before the Fall But all I know of Eden is this high and thorny wall. Tell me – am I faithless that I should speak like this? Must I dress in sack-cloth and mourn the end of bliss? For I was born in exile beneath a fiery sword And cannot dream of walking in the garden of the Lord. . . Patricia Rogers Crozier has been published in The Washington Post. She holds a B.S. in Physics from Mississippi College. She resides in Gulf Breeze, Florida, where she works at the bakery in Publix. NOTE TO READERS: If you enjoyed this poem or other content, please consider making a donation to the Society of Classical Poets. The Society of Classical Poets does not endorse any views expressed in individual poems or commentary. Share this:Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Click to print (Opens in new window)Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)Trending now: 13 Responses Monika Cooper May 22, 2023 This is tremendous. “For I never breathed the jasmine in the garden of the Lord”! Mesmerizing rhythm in the long lines. And what a gift you have for phrases: “orchard door,” “shady ivy maze” just to name a couple. Reply Monika Cooper May 23, 2023 How much can be lost in just a couple generations. “Stories” are important: but are they enough? Reply Paul Freeman May 22, 2023 Well argued, Patricia. Collective punishment is not the fairest of punishments. Thanks for an enlightening read. Reply Joshua C. Frank May 23, 2023 Collective punishment isn’t exactly how Christian theology thinks of it. It’s more that once Adam and Eve sinned, they became addicted to sin and passed that on to us like a drug addiction. Our sinful nature requires us to suffer in order to become fit for Heaven, just as severe illness can require a doctor to do painful things to us to make us well again. Reply Tom Woodliff May 22, 2023 Love this. I’m an avid Bible reader for forty years and never considered the perspective of Cain’s children. Nicely done Reply Roy Eugene Peterson May 22, 2023 Patricia, that is such a beautiful, baleful poem that resonates with wonderful phrases that are enchanting and highly descriptive! Loved it! Reply Paul Erlandson May 22, 2023 Thanks for this poem, Patricia. I like it when poets speak from an uncommon point-of-view, and Cain’s daughter certainly qualifies! One does wonder how accurate was the version of events that got passed down from Cain to his family, given our human tendency for revising history to our own advantage. Reply Norma Pain May 22, 2023 I love this poem. It is so beautifully written and I just want to read it over and over again. It goes into my ‘favorites’ file. Thank you Patricia. Reply Christopher Lindsay May 22, 2023 I enjoyed reading this poem. It’s very re-readable. I am curious– what is the meter? And what is the structure? The lines seem to vary from 12-15 syllables. Reply Joseph S. Salemi May 22, 2023 It is written in a general iambic heptameter, though some of the lines have glitches where there are less than the expected 14 syllables. The glitches can be elided over in a viva-voce reading. Reply Christopher Lindsay May 22, 2023 Thank you. I wasn’t aware of a seven foot line. Joshua C. Frank May 23, 2023 I love the idea of a poem from the perspective of one of Adam’s grandchildren, and you’ve done a good job of writing in her voice. The meter’s a little off in places, but I love the use of imagery. Well done! Reply Monika Cooper May 30, 2023 I may be going out on a limb here, since in meter and the other sub-verbal aspects of poetry, I meet the limits of my powers of analysis. But it seems to me that there’s another level of rhythm in this poem in tension with the iambs and disrupting them. I felt it in the poet’s other piece here at the site as well: Gloucester in July. (Maybe it’s trochees?) Gloucester in July at least scans out mostly trochaic for me and it gives the poem a hammering insistence. Cain’s Daughter may be an instance of what Hopkins called counterpoint in poetry. I find the rhythms in Patricia Roger Crozier’s poems here uniquely exciting, with stronger stresses taking the lead. Reply Leave a Reply Cancel ReplyYour email address will not be published.CommentName* Email* Website Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Notify me of new posts by email. Δ This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Monika Cooper May 22, 2023 This is tremendous. “For I never breathed the jasmine in the garden of the Lord”! Mesmerizing rhythm in the long lines. And what a gift you have for phrases: “orchard door,” “shady ivy maze” just to name a couple. Reply
Monika Cooper May 23, 2023 How much can be lost in just a couple generations. “Stories” are important: but are they enough? Reply
Paul Freeman May 22, 2023 Well argued, Patricia. Collective punishment is not the fairest of punishments. Thanks for an enlightening read. Reply
Joshua C. Frank May 23, 2023 Collective punishment isn’t exactly how Christian theology thinks of it. It’s more that once Adam and Eve sinned, they became addicted to sin and passed that on to us like a drug addiction. Our sinful nature requires us to suffer in order to become fit for Heaven, just as severe illness can require a doctor to do painful things to us to make us well again. Reply
Tom Woodliff May 22, 2023 Love this. I’m an avid Bible reader for forty years and never considered the perspective of Cain’s children. Nicely done Reply
Roy Eugene Peterson May 22, 2023 Patricia, that is such a beautiful, baleful poem that resonates with wonderful phrases that are enchanting and highly descriptive! Loved it! Reply
Paul Erlandson May 22, 2023 Thanks for this poem, Patricia. I like it when poets speak from an uncommon point-of-view, and Cain’s daughter certainly qualifies! One does wonder how accurate was the version of events that got passed down from Cain to his family, given our human tendency for revising history to our own advantage. Reply
Norma Pain May 22, 2023 I love this poem. It is so beautifully written and I just want to read it over and over again. It goes into my ‘favorites’ file. Thank you Patricia. Reply
Christopher Lindsay May 22, 2023 I enjoyed reading this poem. It’s very re-readable. I am curious– what is the meter? And what is the structure? The lines seem to vary from 12-15 syllables. Reply
Joseph S. Salemi May 22, 2023 It is written in a general iambic heptameter, though some of the lines have glitches where there are less than the expected 14 syllables. The glitches can be elided over in a viva-voce reading. Reply
Joshua C. Frank May 23, 2023 I love the idea of a poem from the perspective of one of Adam’s grandchildren, and you’ve done a good job of writing in her voice. The meter’s a little off in places, but I love the use of imagery. Well done! Reply
Monika Cooper May 30, 2023 I may be going out on a limb here, since in meter and the other sub-verbal aspects of poetry, I meet the limits of my powers of analysis. But it seems to me that there’s another level of rhythm in this poem in tension with the iambs and disrupting them. I felt it in the poet’s other piece here at the site as well: Gloucester in July. (Maybe it’s trochees?) Gloucester in July at least scans out mostly trochaic for me and it gives the poem a hammering insistence. Cain’s Daughter may be an instance of what Hopkins called counterpoint in poetry. I find the rhythms in Patricia Roger Crozier’s poems here uniquely exciting, with stronger stresses taking the lead. Reply