"The Geography Lesson" by Boilly‘To My Daughter’: A Poem by Adam Sedia The Society December 10, 2023 Beauty, Culture, Poetry 16 Comments . To My Daughter A woman’s life is hard, they say—and true, Though now not as our mothers understood: They battled nature’s facts and custom’s due; Your battle will be for true womanhood. Though all men’s ways now lie in reach for you— Toil, battle, woes, cares, bruises, sweat, and blood— Your worth is not in rank or revenue: No woman worth the name deems them her good. Men’s work pales to hers; she brings forth new life, Rears it to selfhood; her strength guards the hearth From vice; her softness mollifies men’s strife. For her true men will strive for goodness, dare To greatness, and will wither in her dearth. The curse of Adam is not Eve’s to bear! . . Adam Sedia (b. 1984) lives in his native Northwest Indiana and practices law as a civil and appellate litigator. In addition to the Society’s publications, his poems and prose works have appeared in The Chained Muse Review, Indiana Voice Journal, and other literary journals. He is also a composer, and his musical works may be heard on his YouTube channel. NOTE TO READERS: If you enjoyed this poem or other content, please consider making a donation to the Society of Classical Poets. The Society of Classical Poets does not endorse any views expressed in individual poems or commentary. Share this:Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Click to print (Opens in new window)Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)Trending now: 16 Responses Roy Eugene Peterson December 10, 2023 Adam, beautiful sentiments for your daughter and reminding us of the true values of womanhood! I am sure your daughter is blessed with your wonderful tribute. Reply Adam Sedia December 16, 2023 Thank you! She’s only four, but I hope she can appreciate it someday. Reply Joseph S. Salemi December 10, 2023 A woman who lies down in labor to give birth to a baby puts her life on the line, just as any soldier who goes into combat at the front. Reply James A. Tweedie December 10, 2023 Well put, and true. A nice highlight to Adam’s fine poem (although with three daughters of my own, I may be somewhat biased) Reply Adam Sedia December 16, 2023 I appreciate how you identified part of the Curse of Eve in contrast to the Curse of Adam. Reply Joshua C. Frank December 17, 2023 Absolutely true. I hear there are cultures that honor a woman who died in childbirth in the same way they honor a man who died in battle. This would be a good custom for us to adopt. Reply Cynthia Erlandson December 10, 2023 This is lovely, Adam. Thank you. You use the emphatic meter of line 6 to make such a powerful point in such a compact form. The final verse reminds me of what Adam said in “Paradise Lost” about the dreadful idea of having to live without Eve. Reply Margaret Coats December 10, 2023 Adam, this is a valuable consideration of true womanhood–that naturally addresses true manhood as well in lines 12 and 13. I love the expression, “her softness mollifies men’s strife.” This is real, though denied and excoriated at present. Undoubtedly you appreciate the truism that a man needs a woman to civilize him, and a child to stabilize him. Reply Adam Sedia December 16, 2023 It is definitely real — and even though I paid lip service to the idea before, I was shocked at how true it was once I married and had children. Writing from the perspective of a man, I suppose I couldn’t avoid putting that in, since it describes what I want to guide my daughter. I’ve also written a similar sonnet of guidance for my son who is three years older, but for some reason have not published it yet. Reply Daniel Kemper December 13, 2023 I really felt the addressing true manhood, just in the measure that you did, really brought out the praise of true womanhood –especially the pun in the final line (bear) “The curse of Adam is not Eve’s to bear!” Reply Hari Hyde December 13, 2023 Thanks for this poignant poem on motherhood, which I reread with pleasure. Ancient wisdom is wobbling today, but biology will win in the end, I believe. I fear even more for our nation’s sons rummaging for an identity. Reply Adam Sedia December 16, 2023 We are really playing with fire. The last group you want to make angry is unmarried young men. Reply Joshua C. Frank December 14, 2023 Well said. I agree 100% with every line! In fact, I want to keep this to read to any daughters I have someday. Many conservatives rightly lament modern culture’s belief in the biological interchangeability of the sexes, but it’s a direct result of belief in the economic and social interchangeability of the sexes. There’s little difference between a career woman and a female-to-male transsexual when the chips are down. From what I hear, women aren’t happy with this arrangement foisted upon them by feminists. Masculine women aren’t attractive to men, just as feminine men aren’t attractive to women. (Even when they’re married, they engage in marital intimacy less often.) Hence my poem “In Eve’s Footsteps”—it sounds as if you agree with the principles behind it. Reply Adam Sedia December 16, 2023 You address one of the great taboos of our times. that the things women “fought for” turned out not to be worth the “fight.” I see this all the time in my professional life; it is full of miserable people, men as much as women, but especially with the women I think, “My God, why would you choose THIS?” I could fill pages with my thoughts on this topic, but suffice it to say I agree. Reply Joseph S. Salemi December 17, 2023 Adam, you words bring up a memory. About 40 years ago, in the heyday of “feminist consciousness,” there was a female professor at the university where I then worked. The time arrived when our new union contract came up for negotiation, and naturally everyone on the faculty looked forward to a raise in salary. All, that is, except this woman. She argued vehemently in our union meeting for NO SALARY RAISE AT ALL. Her reason was this, to paraphrase her: “The male faculty at this school are already adequately paid! As a result, their wives can stay home and have a leisurely life. I don’t think we should encourage that! Let these women get off their butts and go out into the world of hard work! More money for their husbands just means that these wives will be pampered even more!” I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. She was arguing against her own financial interest to satisfy a personal ideological grudge against married women, against childbearing, and against homemakers. That’s feminism in action. Joshua C. Frank December 17, 2023 Joe, I’m not the least bit surprised. Feminism is all about destroying everything good about women, and men for that matter. I invite all readers to take a look at this article: https://mallorymillett.com/?p=37 Leave a Reply Cancel ReplyYour email address will not be published.CommentName* Email* Website Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Notify me of new posts by email. Δ This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Roy Eugene Peterson December 10, 2023 Adam, beautiful sentiments for your daughter and reminding us of the true values of womanhood! I am sure your daughter is blessed with your wonderful tribute. Reply
Adam Sedia December 16, 2023 Thank you! She’s only four, but I hope she can appreciate it someday. Reply
Joseph S. Salemi December 10, 2023 A woman who lies down in labor to give birth to a baby puts her life on the line, just as any soldier who goes into combat at the front. Reply
James A. Tweedie December 10, 2023 Well put, and true. A nice highlight to Adam’s fine poem (although with three daughters of my own, I may be somewhat biased) Reply
Adam Sedia December 16, 2023 I appreciate how you identified part of the Curse of Eve in contrast to the Curse of Adam. Reply
Joshua C. Frank December 17, 2023 Absolutely true. I hear there are cultures that honor a woman who died in childbirth in the same way they honor a man who died in battle. This would be a good custom for us to adopt. Reply
Cynthia Erlandson December 10, 2023 This is lovely, Adam. Thank you. You use the emphatic meter of line 6 to make such a powerful point in such a compact form. The final verse reminds me of what Adam said in “Paradise Lost” about the dreadful idea of having to live without Eve. Reply
Margaret Coats December 10, 2023 Adam, this is a valuable consideration of true womanhood–that naturally addresses true manhood as well in lines 12 and 13. I love the expression, “her softness mollifies men’s strife.” This is real, though denied and excoriated at present. Undoubtedly you appreciate the truism that a man needs a woman to civilize him, and a child to stabilize him. Reply
Adam Sedia December 16, 2023 It is definitely real — and even though I paid lip service to the idea before, I was shocked at how true it was once I married and had children. Writing from the perspective of a man, I suppose I couldn’t avoid putting that in, since it describes what I want to guide my daughter. I’ve also written a similar sonnet of guidance for my son who is three years older, but for some reason have not published it yet. Reply
Daniel Kemper December 13, 2023 I really felt the addressing true manhood, just in the measure that you did, really brought out the praise of true womanhood –especially the pun in the final line (bear) “The curse of Adam is not Eve’s to bear!” Reply
Hari Hyde December 13, 2023 Thanks for this poignant poem on motherhood, which I reread with pleasure. Ancient wisdom is wobbling today, but biology will win in the end, I believe. I fear even more for our nation’s sons rummaging for an identity. Reply
Adam Sedia December 16, 2023 We are really playing with fire. The last group you want to make angry is unmarried young men. Reply
Joshua C. Frank December 14, 2023 Well said. I agree 100% with every line! In fact, I want to keep this to read to any daughters I have someday. Many conservatives rightly lament modern culture’s belief in the biological interchangeability of the sexes, but it’s a direct result of belief in the economic and social interchangeability of the sexes. There’s little difference between a career woman and a female-to-male transsexual when the chips are down. From what I hear, women aren’t happy with this arrangement foisted upon them by feminists. Masculine women aren’t attractive to men, just as feminine men aren’t attractive to women. (Even when they’re married, they engage in marital intimacy less often.) Hence my poem “In Eve’s Footsteps”—it sounds as if you agree with the principles behind it. Reply
Adam Sedia December 16, 2023 You address one of the great taboos of our times. that the things women “fought for” turned out not to be worth the “fight.” I see this all the time in my professional life; it is full of miserable people, men as much as women, but especially with the women I think, “My God, why would you choose THIS?” I could fill pages with my thoughts on this topic, but suffice it to say I agree. Reply
Joseph S. Salemi December 17, 2023 Adam, you words bring up a memory. About 40 years ago, in the heyday of “feminist consciousness,” there was a female professor at the university where I then worked. The time arrived when our new union contract came up for negotiation, and naturally everyone on the faculty looked forward to a raise in salary. All, that is, except this woman. She argued vehemently in our union meeting for NO SALARY RAISE AT ALL. Her reason was this, to paraphrase her: “The male faculty at this school are already adequately paid! As a result, their wives can stay home and have a leisurely life. I don’t think we should encourage that! Let these women get off their butts and go out into the world of hard work! More money for their husbands just means that these wives will be pampered even more!” I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. She was arguing against her own financial interest to satisfy a personal ideological grudge against married women, against childbearing, and against homemakers. That’s feminism in action.
Joshua C. Frank December 17, 2023 Joe, I’m not the least bit surprised. Feminism is all about destroying everything good about women, and men for that matter. I invite all readers to take a look at this article: https://mallorymillett.com/?p=37