Frankenstein illustration (public domain)‘What Is a Man?’: A Poem by Cynthia Erlandson The Society June 16, 2025 Culture, Poetry 8 Comments . What Is a Man? “Ask now, and see, whether a man is ever in labor with child?” —Jeremiah 30: 6 The prophet’s statement clearly is sarcastic; That men cannot birth children is well-known. But now we’re told we may not look askance At anyone who claims he can (with drastic Surgeries, or senseless change of pron- ouns) overthrow the laws of common sense And nature. Such a lucrative transaction For surgeons, yields a permanently tragic Consequence to those who’ve been deceived Regarding actual damage the subtraction Of manhood will impose. This new barbaric Practice from the start was ill-conceived By villains who were pregnant with sadistic Plans to enrich themselves, in bold defiance Of the physician’s oath—the Hippocratic Vow to Do No Harm. With egotistic Aplomb, miscarrying the name of Science, They mock all disapproval as fanatic. In sinister disguise of sympathetic Specialists, their labor is delusion: Experimenting in reality- denial (which an honorable medic Would never do), engendering confusion, Committing crimes against humanity. Beware of phony doctors—Frankensteins Who perpetrate atrocities, whose trans- formations prove they are uncivilized Criminals. With damaging designs, They desecrate the dignity of man’s Image, and dissect dehumanized Humanity. If insanity defines Identity, results are pathologic, Destroying men and their societies. When language is abused, the world declines; When science fails to maintain biologic Truth, the world accepts absurdities. Predictably, a culture’s quick demise Impends when words, and people, are defined By lethal lies and transient fantasies. When savage surgeons deviously devise Abuse; when ill-used grammar undermines Communication’s clear vocabularies; When cold-hearted technology aligns With human avarice, the diagnosis Can easily be read between the lines: A devastating cultural necrosis. . . Cynthia Erlandson is a poet and fitness professional living in Michigan. Her third collection of poems, Foundations of the Cross and Other Bible Stories, was released in July, 2024 by Wipf and Stock Publishers. Her other collections are These Holy Mysteries and Notes on Time. Her poems have also appeared in First Things, Modern Age, The North American Anglican, The Orchards Poetry Review, The Book of Common Praise hymnal, The Catholic Poetry Room, and elsewhere. NOTE TO READERS: If you enjoyed this poem or other content, please consider making a donation to the Society of Classical Poets. The Society of Classical Poets does not endorse any views expressed in individual poems or commentary. ***Read Our Comments Policy Here*** 8 Responses Roy Eugene Peterson June 17, 2025 Cynthia, these are some great words and great lines. You defined the atrocities perfectly as crimes. Such cultures cannot continue on without consequences. You continue to impress me with your poetic skills and creative mind. Thank you. Reply Cynthia L Erlandson June 17, 2025 Thank you so much, Roy. I’m glad you find the poem meaningful and creative. Reply Joseph S. Salemi June 17, 2025 Cynthia makes an important point: the horrors perpetrated in laboratories and hospitals only happen AFTER the debasement and muddying of language prepares the ground. This is why the political left is fixated on linguistic usage and terminology, as Orwell pointed out in his dystopian novel “1984”. Reply Cynthia L Erlandson June 17, 2025 Thank you, Joseph. Yes — I don’t recall exactly when I started noticing language-abuse, but it may have been with the ridiculous phrase “pro-choice” to mean a choice about only one thing, and that a cruel one. Now, I seriously doubt whether anyone in the “trans community” (“community” is another abused word) could even define the prefix “trans”. I’m so grateful that this Society is here to be part of the battle to retrieve the beauty and meaning of our language. Reply James Sale June 17, 2025 Love that unexpected last word, Cynthia: necrosis!! Yes, modern culture – very nice indeed! Reply Cynthia L Erlandson June 17, 2025 Thank you, James. Reply Warren Bonham June 17, 2025 I must have read that Jeremiah passage several times, but it never really registered before. That’s a perfect introduction for your fantastic poem. Frankenstein was given free rein, but it feels like the pendulum is moving slowly in the right direction. Reply Cynthia L Erlandson June 17, 2025 Thanks, Warren; indeed, my eyes popped when I ran across the Jeremiah verse this time, as it seemed to have taken on a surprising new meaning! I hope you’re right that the pendulum is moving back in the right direction. Reply Leave a Reply Cancel ReplyYour email address will not be published.CommentName* Email* Website Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting. Δ This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Roy Eugene Peterson June 17, 2025 Cynthia, these are some great words and great lines. You defined the atrocities perfectly as crimes. Such cultures cannot continue on without consequences. You continue to impress me with your poetic skills and creative mind. Thank you. Reply
Cynthia L Erlandson June 17, 2025 Thank you so much, Roy. I’m glad you find the poem meaningful and creative. Reply
Joseph S. Salemi June 17, 2025 Cynthia makes an important point: the horrors perpetrated in laboratories and hospitals only happen AFTER the debasement and muddying of language prepares the ground. This is why the political left is fixated on linguistic usage and terminology, as Orwell pointed out in his dystopian novel “1984”. Reply
Cynthia L Erlandson June 17, 2025 Thank you, Joseph. Yes — I don’t recall exactly when I started noticing language-abuse, but it may have been with the ridiculous phrase “pro-choice” to mean a choice about only one thing, and that a cruel one. Now, I seriously doubt whether anyone in the “trans community” (“community” is another abused word) could even define the prefix “trans”. I’m so grateful that this Society is here to be part of the battle to retrieve the beauty and meaning of our language. Reply
James Sale June 17, 2025 Love that unexpected last word, Cynthia: necrosis!! Yes, modern culture – very nice indeed! Reply
Warren Bonham June 17, 2025 I must have read that Jeremiah passage several times, but it never really registered before. That’s a perfect introduction for your fantastic poem. Frankenstein was given free rein, but it feels like the pendulum is moving slowly in the right direction. Reply
Cynthia L Erlandson June 17, 2025 Thanks, Warren; indeed, my eyes popped when I ran across the Jeremiah verse this time, as it seemed to have taken on a surprising new meaning! I hope you’re right that the pendulum is moving back in the right direction. Reply